There was a robust discussion on the merits and novelty of this work after the rebuttal from the authors. There was some confusion as to whether this work is truly the first to-be-published work that introduces BrainScore. We concluded that given the pre-print only versions of the work thus far, this qualifies as a genuinely new contribution (wrt. to the NeurIPS guidelines). With that in mind: the authors would do well do describe the details of the BrainScore in more detail in the camera ready version. Otherwise, everyone is excited about the novel aspects (architecture, experiments, metric etc) of this work so I wholeheartedly recommend this work to be accepted at NeurIPS.