NeurIPS 2019
Sun Dec 8th through Sat the 14th, 2019 at Vancouver Convention Center
Paper ID:5283
Title:Transductive Zero-Shot Learning with Visual Structure Constraint

The submission originally received scores mixed region that put it into the borderline region. The reviewers praised the simple and apparently effective method, but also noted a number of issues, in particular an unclear relation to [34] (which itself is rather unclear) as well as an insufficient experiment evaluation. In their response the authors provided additional information and results, which the reviewers appreciated. A detailed discussion followed, that ultimately let to the conclusion that the contribution is valuable and that authors should not be punished for a lack of clarity in the prior work [34]. Therefore, the recommendation is to accept the work. The authors are encourage to incorporate the reviewer suggestions and the material of the rebuttal into the camera-ready manuscript.