NeurIPS 2020

Manifold structure in graph embeddings

Meta Review

Three of the four reports are clearly positive. The only review that is somewhat critical explains its lower score by lack of direct applications. I agree, but do not see that as a problem: NeurIPS has a long history of publishing foundational work, the topic of the paper falls clearly within the remit of the conference, and foundational and theoretical work on embeddings is still rare; I would consider this work a welcome exception. The rebuttal promises a number of revisions; please make sure to add these in the final version.